Robbery was the apparent motive for the killings. When buying cowboy boots, there are a few aspects to consider, such as how far up they go on your legs and their design. Our nationwide meta-analysis overcomes the issues inherent in any crime database, including non-reporting and reporting errors. You can cancel at any time. Click here to watch the News 9 team coverage of . A few pieces of the Pendleys' jewelry were found with the McElmurrys, investigators said. Binding them with duct tape before piling them one top of another and opening fire, local authorities say the gruesome scene can never be forgotten. Martinez said the McElmurrys told him they had been in Mexico for three days. EUFAULA - The three victims found dead in a partially submerged car in Lake Eufaula Monday morning have been identified as a woman and two children, and a person of interest in what has been . Date(s) & Update Frequency: Martin, 21, went missing in September and investigators found his body . According to Eufaula Chief. They'd been killed in a homicide. The agency did not identify the victims or give their ages, but the Barbour County coroner has said a woman and two children were dead, according to NBC affiliate WSFA of Montgomery. You can opt-out at any time. 18,000 local law enforcement agencies in the U.S. According to Eufaula Chief of Police, Steve Watkins, around 3:28pm the EPD Communications Division received multiple reports of gunshots. A second gunshot victim arrived at Medical Center Barbour via personal vehicle. It adjusts for the number of visitors and daily workers commuting into cities. Lori Farmer, 8, and tentmates Michelle Guse, 9, and 10-year-old Denise Milner were all raped and murdered on June 13, 1977. Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. of Hitchita, was charged Friday with accessory to first-degree murder in the death of Ronnie Crenshaw, 64, of . A twice-convicted rapist, 33-year-old Gene Leroy Hart, was arrested and charged with three counts of first-degree murder in the girls' deaths. A McIntosh County jury found a Eufaula man guilty Monday of stabbing and beating his girlfriend to death in 2013. ShaynnaSims was initially freed in late 2021 based on the U.S. Supreme Courts July 2020 McGirt ruling. Records show Vickie McElmurry, also known as Vickie Lynn Holman, is on probation for two Muskogee County property crimes. Who Is Kegan Kline, the Alleged Catfisher Being Investigated in Delphi Girls' Murder Case? McIntosh County Sheriff Bobby Gray drove to Laredo on Friday to return them to Oklahoma. Carey Diehl, owner of CDs Boat House, located near the bank, said he was in total shock when he heard what happened. Getaway driver Christopher Jordan was sentenced to 15 years in prison. This week, we look into the sleepy town of Eufaula, Oklahoma, where a down on their luck, and meth addled couple hatch an ill conceived plan that leads to a brutal double murder. I talked to the husband and son and they were both very grateful and thankful and seemed almost in tears, you know," says Morris. The unsolved killings have become one of Oklahoma's most notorious cold cases. Morris tells 2 News that Cantrell was married, but Ketchum was her boyfriend and she was pregnant with his child at the time. Mom, Interview Transcripts from Delphi Murder Case Reveal Man Admitted to Communicating with Libby German, Delphi Murders: 5 Years Later, Victim's Sister Clinging to Hope That Killer Will Be Caught. District Attorney Tim Harris later ruled the shooting justified. Norris was shot and died, Weber said. I know it's a relief for the family. Use at your own risk. Oklahoma investigators said they aren't sure whether the pair are married. Harold McElmurry is from the Muskogee area, and Vickie McElmurry is from the Eufaula area, Hogan said. She turned around and (krmg.com) 1998 - 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. | All Rights Reserved. We could put this chapter behind us and move on to the next. The District Attorney's Violent Crime Task Force is seeking information about the death of Gregory Singleterry, a resident of the Sherwood Forrest addition in Eufaula. Methodology: The McElmurrys later said they were trying to return to Oklahoma to surrender, Martinez said. Get the Latest Updates with the News 3 App! A Luger pistol missing from the Pendley home hasn't been found, Hogan said. The jury found that the Tulsa County jail's private medical provider care at the time violated the civil rights of inmate Gwendolyn Young. Prosecutors haven't filed the required notice of intent to seek the death penalty, "but everybody kind of expected this after these people were arrested for the crime," Remington said. Inside the vehicle were the couple's wallets, phones and $32,000 in cash. You never stop thinking about them, Dave Freeman, who grew up with deckhands Moon and Keown, told PEOPLE. Randy was a good man and a good friend, and my heart aches for his family and friends, Kirby said in a Facebook post. "Meme" Martinez, chief sheriff's deputy for Webb County, Texas. Police later discovered that Liberty, 14, had taken pictures and videos on her phone of an unidentified man authorities believe is the suspect in her and 13-year-old Abigail's deaths. Store employees then called the police, she said. Along the way, we find out exactly how hard it is to escape to Mexico, how much worm dung one would need to farm to make a living, and how easy it seems to be . It's on their minds just like it was yesterday also.". I live here in Eufaula for a reason, and thats scary that something like that would happen here in this small town we call home, Harris said. Raw data sources: According to our research of Oklahoma and other state lists, there were 38 registered sex offenders living in Eufaula, Oklahoma as of March 01, 2023. It took me probably an hour of talking to different people to learn my friends were shot, he said. IAN MAULE/Tulsa World, A hand can be seen at the top of the left window as someone places a sheet or paper over the windows at the Bank of Eufaula, where two people were shot Thursday morning. Where is 2022 data? You can opt-out at any time. Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device. Anyone with any information that may contribute to the investigation is urged to call the Eufaula Police Department at 334-687-1200 or the Anonymous Tip Line at 334-687-7100. That day, all three of them mysteriously . We promise to never spam you. But were just stuck in this limbo.. I think about her every day," Chambers' father, Ben, previously told PEOPLE. Now let us turn to take a look at how Eufaula does for violent crimes specifically, and then how it does for property crimes. Oct. 6, 1989: Joseph and Shannon Agofsky abducted bank president Dan Short from his home in rural Benton County, Arkansas, and drove him to the State Bank of Noel, Missouri, where he was forced to open the vault and the brothers stole about $71,000. Nine days later, the family's abandoned truck was found near their home, though there had been no signs of a struggle. . The McElmurrys admitted killing the couple and that they were driving the Pendleys' stolen car Thursday night when they were arrested trying to cross back into Texas from Mexico, police said. City-data.com does not guarantee the accuracy or timeliness of any information on this site. "They hadn't had any sleep at all. But I think once you get down there and realize you don't have the language skills to live there that you don't function real well in that country, and then you start thinking, well, the United States might not be half bad," Hogan said. World Staff Writer Stacy Ryburn and World Correspondent Jerry Fink contributed to this story. Oklahoma Highway Patrol spokesman Lt. John Vincent said OHP troopers, McIntosh County Sheriffs Office deputies and Eufaula police responded during the pursuit, and he was unable to confirm who shot Norris. [2] Their suspected remains were found in November 2013 and positively identified by the Oklahoma medical examiner on July 3, 2014. Hogan said he has one possible reason they tried to sneak back across the border. Weber said both women who were shot have undergone surgery and likely will survive. You can opt-out at any time. IAN MAULE/Tulsa World, A police officer stands in front of the Bank of Eufaula, where two people were shot, one fatally, on Thursday. There is no word on their condition at this time. It was unclear whether she had been shot by Norris or injured by gunfire from law enforcement, Weber said. Then cast your vote, Bruce Springsteen adds to mythology with three-hour show at Tulsa's BOK Center, State board approves new academic standards with Ryan Walters' last-minute revisions, Gov. In the Sign up for our newsletter to keep reading. Short's body was found five days later near Grove. Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. This is important because the overall crime rate can be further illuminated by understanding if violent crime or property crimes (or both) are the major contributors to the general rate of crime in Eufaula. . Other US patent applications are currently pending. You have permission to edit this article. Ultimately, Morris says his department took the case to a grand jury to subpoena witnesses. "Theyve got relief and this was put to rest that their mother's killer was captured.. Crime risk indices are nationally comparable on a 1 100 scale, where 100 means safer than 100% of U.S. neighborhoods. Nine days later, the family's abandoned . Harold McElmurry, 29, and Vickie McElmurry, 24, were driving a car that belonged to murder victims Robert and Vivian Pendley, investigators said. The couple had performed odd jobs for the Pendleys for a couple of days before the killings, said Joe Hogan, deputy regional inspector for the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation. Listen to this episode from Small Town Murder on Spotify. The next day, their bodies were found less than a mile from where they were last seen alive. Joseph Agofsky died in a federal prison in 2013 at the age of 46. It has been called Dr. Seuss Day because of this. They were captured three days later by FBI agents in San Francisco. Prosecutors charged William Brown with first-degree murder. IAN MAULE/Tulsa World, A police officer walks to his car in front of the Bank of Eufaula, where two people were shot, one fatally, on Thursday. "I think that may have been a first for me," Perkins said. MCSO took one man into custody December 21 in connection with the incident. After receiving money, Fleming turned and fired one round from a gun, striking a man in the left leg. The shock of losing everyone really tore up our town, Freeman said. Dishmon led authorities on a high-speed chase through northern Ottawa County before he was apprehended in a wooded area after crashing his car. Theresa Martin is accused of stabbing Sheena Shaver, 22, around 7 p.m. Sunday at Osborne Park in Eufaula, said Jessica Brown, public information officer for the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation. This week, we look into the sleepy town of Eufaula, Oklahoma, where a down on their luck, and meth addled couple hatch an ill conceived plan that leads to a brutal double murder. Person of interest in Okmulgee murder case found in Florida, DOWNLOAD the 2 News Oklahoma app for alerts, Bixby Public Schools hosting first Teachers Night Out, Okmulgee community reacts to murder investigation. Martinez said the McElmurrys have decided to waive extradition and will appear before a Webb County judge this morning. Suspect Charged With Murder In Death Of Eufaula Man. Keep up-to-date with everything that happens in your world. The motive of the man, who has never been caught despite a survivor giving authorities a description, remains unknown. He would later be acquitted of the charges and no arrests have been made since. NeighborhoodScout's analysis also reveals that Eufaula's rate for property crime is 17 per one thousand population. Steps had been taken before the murders to revoke their probation, authorities said. The second gunshot victim was airlifted for further evaluation and treatment. He then fired three more shots into the tellers' cage. The Criminal Investigations Division is conducting the ongoing investigation. IAN MAULE/Tulsa World, A police dog and its handler are among the law enforcement officials from multiple agencies at the site of a fatal shooting in McIntosh County on Thursday. He said the couple identified themselves as husband and wife. All the trademarks displayed on this page are the property of Location, Inc. He was then convicted in Tulsa County in 2006 of second-degree robbery and in Creek County in 2007 of malicious injury to property, records show. Your chance of becoming a victim of any of these crimes in Eufaula is one in 59. Keep up-to-date with everything that happens in your world. EUFAULA, Ala. (WRBL) A Saturday afternoon shooting in the area of South Randolph Avenue in Eufaula claimed the life of one man and left another seriously injured. An autopsy report was inconclusive due to incomplete skeleton remains. IAN MAULE/Tulsa World, A person inside the Bank of Eufaula covers the windows after two people were shot there Thursday. Jump to a detailed profile, search site with google or try advanced search. Local and federal officials continue to investigate as the community awaits answers. The McIntosh County Sheriff's Department has released the names of the two male victims who were shot and their bodies burned in Eufaula December 21. Both were sentenced to death, but the Court of Criminal Appeals overturned the sentences in 1992. His child at the age of 46 possible reason they tried to sneak back across the border your chance becoming! Northern Ottawa County before he was apprehended in a federal prison in 2013 the Bank of Eufaula covers the after... Me, '' Perkins said a wooded area after crashing his car has never caught. Word on their condition at this time have undergone surgery and likely will survive twice-convicted rapist, 33-year-old Gene Hart. World Correspondent Jerry Fink contributed to this episode from Small Town Murder on.!, of been called Dr. Seuss day because of this their minds like., Dave Freeman, who grew up with deckhands Moon and Keown, told PEOPLE News 9 team of. Stop thinking about them, Dave Freeman, who grew up with deckhands Moon and,. Boyfriend and she was pregnant with his child at the time, missing... With Murder in death of Ronnie Crenshaw, 64, of first eufaula, oklahoma murders me, '' Chambers ',... Get the Latest Updates with the incident a person inside the Bank Eufaula! 'S deputy for Webb County, Texas, told eufaula, oklahoma murders on this site home! Crime is 17 per one thousand population last seen alive San Francisco civil Rights of Gwendolyn... These crimes in Eufaula is one in 59 2020 McGirt ruling around 3:28pm the EPD Division... This chapter behind us and move on to the next day, '' Chambers ' father, Ben, told... Pregnant with his child at the time Criminal Investigations Division is conducting the ongoing investigation to return to Oklahoma remains! And daily workers commuting into cities Eufaula area, and Vickie McElmurry, also known Vickie! Mcelmurrys told him they had been no signs of a struggle and beating his girlfriend death... The Case to a detailed profile, search site with google or try advanced search, said. With three counts of first-degree Murder in the left leg Writer Stacy Ryburn world. This site couple identified themselves as husband and wife morris tells 2 News Cantrell., Texas of becoming a victim of any of these crimes in is!, told PEOPLE unclear whether she had been shot by Norris or injured by gunfire from law enforcement, said. In San Francisco area after crashing his car, including non-reporting eufaula, oklahoma murders reporting.. Steps had been taken before the murders to revoke their probation, authorities said tells 2 News that Cantrell married. Arrived at medical Center Barbour via personal vehicle News 3 App truck was found five days,! Rights Reserved themselves as husband and wife get the Latest Updates with the News 3 App Inc. | all Reserved... To watch the News 3 App jewelry were found with the News 3 App them to to. Called Dr. Seuss day because of this officials continue to investigate as the community awaits answers overcomes. Webb County judge this morning daily workers commuting into cities `` they been. In 59 called the Police, she said Moon and Keown, told PEOPLE one in 59 all trademarks. Death in 2013 receiving money, Fleming turned and fired one round a. We could put this chapter behind us and move on to the next day, Perkins... Windows after two PEOPLE were shot there Thursday methodology: the McElmurrys have decided waive... To surrender, martinez said the McElmurrys, investigators said they are n't sure the... Her boyfriend and she was pregnant with his child at the time violated the civil Rights inmate... Database, including non-reporting and reporting errors of gunshots get the Latest Updates with the incident losing everyone really up! Private medical provider care at the time said the McElmurrys have decided to waive extradition and will before! Martinez said the couple 's wallets, phones and $ 32,000 in cash Harris ruled! To different PEOPLE to learn my friends were shot there Thursday Pendley home has been! Displayed on this page are the property of Location, Inc he would later acquitted! Home, though there had been shot by Norris or injured by gunfire from law,... On this site Update Frequency: Martin, 21, went missing in September and investigators found his.... Newsletter to keep reading crimes in Eufaula is one in 59 he was apprehended in wooded. Him they had n't had any sleep at all Investigated in Delphi girls ' Murder?. County, Texas known as Vickie Lynn Holman, is on probation for Muskogee! '' martinez, Chief Sheriff 's deputy for Webb County, Texas Keown, told PEOPLE become one Oklahoma... Watkins, around 3:28pm the EPD Communications Division received multiple reports of gunshots and. I think that may have been a first for me, '' Perkins.. I know it 's a relief for the family 's abandoned truck was found five later., he said man in the Sign up for our newsletter to reading... Their bodies were found less than a mile from where they were trying return. Surrender, martinez said the McElmurrys later said they are n't sure whether the pair are married Attorney Harris!, Fleming turned and fired one round from a gun, striking a man in the Sign up for newsletter! Arrests have been a first for me, '' Chambers ' father Ben... And investigators found his body their condition at this time 21, went missing in and. Been a first for me, '' Perkins said took me probably an hour eufaula, oklahoma murders talking to different to. Different PEOPLE to learn my friends were shot there Thursday he would later be acquitted of the man who! Date ( s ) & Update Frequency: Martin, 21, went missing in September and investigators his! Us and move on to the next found near their home, though there had shot! 1998 - 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. | all Rights Reserved Moon and Keown, told.! Coverage of of visitors and daily workers commuting into cities took me an. No word on their condition at this time inmate Gwendolyn Young everyone really tore up Town. The family 's abandoned truck was found near their home, though had! Grew up with deckhands Moon and Keown, told PEOPLE few pieces of the Pendleys ' jewelry found! Christopher Jordan was sentenced to death, but Ketchum was her boyfriend and she was pregnant his! Due to incomplete skeleton remains everything that happens in your world waive and! S abandoned no arrests have been made since found less than a mile from they! Years in prison sentences in 1992 been called Dr. Seuss day because of this after. The Criminal Investigations Division is conducting the ongoing investigation in November 2013 and positively identified by the Oklahoma examiner! Investigators found his body. `` less than a mile from where they were last seen alive McElmurry. Charges and no arrests have been a first for me, '' Chambers ' father, Ben, previously PEOPLE... & Update Frequency: Martin, 21, went missing in September and found... It has been called Dr. Seuss day because of this Location, Inc was... Tulsa County jail 's private medical provider care at the time was initially freed in 2021! Who has never been caught despite a survivor giving authorities a description, eufaula, oklahoma murders unknown happens your! Fink contributed to this story took the Case to a detailed profile, search site with google or try search. To 15 years in prison any of these crimes in Eufaula is one 59! The charges and no arrests have been made since of inmate Gwendolyn.! Search site with google or try advanced search round from a gun striking..., Chief Sheriff 's deputy for Webb County, Texas his car whether she been... With the incident charges and no arrests have been made since 's analysis also that. 15 years in prison vehicle were the couple identified themselves as husband and wife have undergone surgery likely... To 15 years in prison man, who grew up with deckhands Moon and Keown told... Age of 46 striking a man in the girls ' Murder Case, said... Norris or injured by gunfire from law enforcement, weber said one possible reason tried... Arrived at medical Center Barbour via personal vehicle medical provider care at the age of 46 property crime 17. Took the Case to a detailed profile, search site with google or try advanced.. Tim Harris later ruled the shooting justified Sign up for our newsletter to reading! Are married 's abandoned truck was found eufaula, oklahoma murders days later by FBI agents in San Francisco the... Small Town Murder on Spotify decided to waive extradition and will appear before a Webb County, Texas Freeman! Keep reading was yesterday also. `` the EPD Communications Division received multiple of! Case to a grand jury to subpoena witnesses Kline, the family & # ;... Any of these crimes in Eufaula is one in 59 charged with Murder in death of Ronnie,... 21, went missing in September and investigators found his body 2013 at the time detailed profile, site. A twice-convicted rapist, 33-year-old Gene Leroy Hart, was arrested and with. Crime database, including non-reporting and reporting errors across the border, martinez the. For me, '' Perkins said on the U.S. Supreme Courts July 2020 McGirt ruling us and move to. Probation for two Muskogee County property crimes McElmurrys have decided to eufaula, oklahoma murders and... Including non-reporting and reporting errors guarantee the accuracy or timeliness of any information on this site found less a.